Filing Income Tax Return in India for NRIs
ITR-2 and ITR-3 preparation · TDS reconciliation and refund recovery · capital gains on Indian property · treaty relief claims — filed remotely from our Pune office
Why an NRI Return Is Worth Filing
Most non-residents who should file an Indian return do not, and most who do file lose money doing it. The two errors are connected. Tax is deducted at source on Indian rent, on interest and on sale proceeds at rates set for non-residents, which are deliberately conservative and frequently far above the actual liability. Unless a return is filed, that excess is not refunded. It is simply kept.
The amounts are rarely small. Tax withheld on the sale of an Indian property is computed on the whole consideration before any deduction for cost of acquisition, indexation or reinvestment exemption. A seller with a modest actual gain can find a very substantial sum deducted, recoverable only by filing. The same pattern applies, on a smaller scale, every year on rent and NRO interest.
N D Savla & Associates prepares and files Indian income tax returns for non-residents from our Pune office, working entirely remotely with clients across the Gulf, North America, the United Kingdom, Singapore and Australia. Everything begins with residential status, because the status determines what has to be reported before anything is computed.
What Does NRI Return Filing Involve?
An Indian return for a non-resident is narrower in scope than a resident return but more demanding in three specific areas: establishing residential status, reconciling withholding against the tax credit statements, and claiming treaty relief with the documentation the Act requires.
The scope of income to be reported is limited to Indian sources:
- Rental income from property situated in India, after the standard deduction and municipal taxes
- Capital gains on Indian shares, mutual funds, bonds and immovable property
- Interest on NRO deposits and on other Indian deposits and bonds
- Dividends from Indian companies
- Salary received in India or for services rendered in India
- Business or professional income arising through an Indian source or presence
Income arising and received outside India is outside the Indian net for a non-resident, and certain Indian receipts are exempt outright. Those are set out separately in our note on exempt income for NRIs.
Who Needs to File an Indian Return?
Five situations account for most non-resident filings, and only the first is a strict legal obligation.
NRIs With Indian Income Above the Threshold
Where total Indian income before deductions exceeds the basic exemption limit, filing is mandatory. The threshold is applied to gross total income, so a person whose income falls below it only after claiming deductions is still required to file.
NRIs Who Have Sold Indian Property
This group has the largest amounts at stake. Withholding on a sale to a non-resident is applied without regard to the seller's actual cost, indexation or reinvestment plans, so the deduction routinely exceeds the real liability by a wide margin. Recovering it requires a return supported by a proper capital gains computation.
NRIs Earning Rent or NRO Interest
Rent paid to a non-resident and interest credited to an NRO account attract deduction at non-resident rates. Where the person has no other Indian income, the annual liability is frequently nil or minimal and the whole deduction is refundable, but only on filing.
NRIs Claiming Treaty Relief
Where income is taxed both in India and in the country of residence, treaty relief reduces the overall burden. Claiming it formally requires the return to be filed with the supporting documentation, and it is the return rather than the correspondence with the payer that establishes the position for the year. This connects to the double taxation avoidance framework.
NRIs Carrying Forward Capital Losses
Losses on Indian shares, mutual funds or property can be carried forward and set against future gains, but only where the return is filed by the original due date. A belated return preserves everything else and forfeits this. For anyone with an active Indian portfolio, that alone justifies filing on time.
How Has NRI Taxation Developed in India?
The framework for taxing non-residents was built to attract capital rather than to raise revenue, and much of its structure still reflects that purpose.
Chapter XII-A and a Closed Economy
Foreign exchange was scarce and tightly controlled under the regime of the time. To attract remittances from Indians working abroad, a special chapter was inserted into the Income Tax Act in the early nineteen eighties offering non-residents a concessional flat rate on investment income from specified foreign exchange assets, an exemption on long-term gains reinvested in such assets, and relief from the obligation to file in defined circumstances. These provisions were an inducement, not a burden.
Liberalisation and Rising Remittances
Economic liberalisation transformed both the volume of Indian emigration and the ease of moving money. Remittances grew rapidly, non-resident deposits became macroeconomically significant, and the exchange control framework was replaced in 1999 with a management rather than a regulation statute. The tax framework, however, remained largely as designed for the earlier era.
Electronic Filing and Treaty Scrutiny
Electronic filing was introduced and progressively made compulsory, which for the first time made it practical for a non-resident to file from abroad without an Indian representative. At the same time, treaty relief came under scrutiny, and the requirement to hold a tax residency certificate from the country of residence was introduced to substantiate a treaty claim.
Documentation and Data Matching
Treaty documentation was tightened further, with a self-declaration required in addition to the residency certificate where the certificate does not carry all the prescribed particulars. Reporting of tax deducted at source was expanded and matched against returns, so a mismatch between what a payer reported and what a taxpayer claimed became visible automatically rather than only on scrutiny.
Residence Rules Rewritten and Full Data Visibility
The residence tests were amended to bring in categories of individuals who had previously remained non-resident everywhere, and a concessional alternative tax regime was introduced. On the administrative side, the annual information statement gave taxpayers and the department the same view of reported transactions, and treaty declaration filing moved online. Assessment became faceless, which removed the geographic disadvantage a non-resident previously faced but placed far more weight on what the return itself discloses.
Filed Remotely, Assessed Against Data Already Held
An Indian return for a non-resident is now filed remotely, assessed against data the department already holds, and turns largely on whether the residential status, the withholding reconciliation and the treaty documentation are correct. The concessional provisions of the earlier era remain available to those who qualify, and are widely overlooked.
What Is the Step-by-Step Filing Process?
Step one governs everything else. A return filed on the wrong residential status is wrong regardless of how accurately the income is computed.
Determine Residential Status for the Year
Compute status on day counts across the relevant year and preceding years, applying every applicable test, and record the working so it can be produced if questioned.
Identify and Classify Indian Income
List every Indian source for the year, separating income that is taxable from income that is exempt, and confirm nothing arising outside India has been included in error.
Reconcile Withholding Against the Statements
Match every deduction to the tax credit statement and the annual information statement, and pursue any deduction that has not been reported correctly by the payer.
Compute Capital Gains Properly
Establish cost of acquisition, holding period and indexation where applicable, and quantify any reinvestment exemption being claimed on the sale of property.
Assess Whether the Special Provisions Apply
Where investment income or long-term gains arise from specified foreign exchange assets, test whether the concessional chapter produces a better outcome than normal computation.
Compare the Two Tax Regimes
Compute the liability under both the normal and the concessional regime on the individual's actual deductions, and select the one that produces the lower figure.
Assemble Treaty Documentation Where Relief Is Claimed
Obtain the tax residency certificate from the country of residence and file the prescribed declaration, so the claim is supported at the point it is made.
File, Verify and Track the Refund
File the correct form before the due date, complete verification, ensure a validated Indian bank account is in place to receive any refund, and follow the refund through to credit.
Step three is where most recoverable money is found and lost. Where a tenant or a purchaser has deducted tax but reported it incorrectly, the credit will not appear against the non-resident's account and cannot be claimed. Deductions on payments to non-residents are reported through Form 27Q, and errors there have to be corrected by the deductor rather than by the taxpayer.
What Gets Deducted and What Is Usually Recoverable?
The table shows where the gap between withholding and actual liability typically arises for a non-resident.
| Income | Deduction at Source | Common Position on Filing |
|---|---|---|
| Sale of Indian property | Applied on gross consideration | Large refund after cost, indexation and exemptions |
| Rent from Indian property | Applied on gross rent | Refund after standard deduction and municipal taxes |
| NRO interest | Applied at non-resident rate | Often fully refundable where no other Indian income |
| Listed share and mutual fund gains | Applied at prescribed rates | Adjusted for losses, exemptions and holding period |
| Dividends from Indian companies | Applied at non-resident rate | Frequently reduced under a treaty |
Where NRI Returns Commonly Go Wrong
Four errors account for most of the corrective work we are asked to do.
The Wrong Form
A non-resident cannot file on the simplified form intended for resident individuals with basic income. A return filed on it is treated as defective, and the correction cycle can push the filing past the due date, forfeiting loss carry-forward in the process.
Residential Status Assumed Rather Than Computed
People assume they remain non-resident because they live abroad, without counting days actually spent in India. A year with extended family visits can change the status, which changes what has to be reported. The amended residence tests have widened this trap considerably.
Treaty Relief Claimed Without Documentation
A treaty rate applied by a payer without the residency certificate and prescribed declaration on file is vulnerable. The tax residency certificate has to be obtained from the foreign tax authority for the relevant period, and the declaration filed, before relief is claimed rather than after a query.
Concessional Provisions Never Considered
The special chapter for non-residents can produce a materially better outcome on investment income and on long-term gains from specified assets, and it is routinely ignored by generalist preparers. Whether it applies is set out in our note on the special provisions for non-residents.
Why Choose N D Savla & Associates for NRI Return Filing?
This work rewards a preparer who understands what a non-resident return should not contain as much as what it should.
Residential Status Computed and Documented
We compute status from actual day counts across every applicable test and retain the working. This is the foundation of the return and the first thing examined if the filing is questioned.
Withholding Chased, Not Just Reported
Where a deduction does not appear correctly in the credit statements, we identify it and pursue correction with the deductor. Credit that has not been reported cannot be claimed, and most taxpayers never discover it is missing.
Certificates Obtained Before Transactions
For anticipated property sales we apply for a lower deduction certificate ahead of the transaction, so the correct amount is withheld at source instead of a refund being pursued for a year afterwards.
Both Regimes and the Special Provisions Compared
Every return is computed under the normal regime, the concessional regime and, where relevant, the special chapter for non-residents, and filed on whichever produces the lowest liability. This comparison takes minutes and is regularly skipped.
Handled Remotely, Filed From Pune
Documents are collected, queries resolved and returns filed on the income tax portal without the client needing to be in India, and any subsequent notice is handled from here. Our office at Baner, Pune serves non-resident clients across time zones.
Frequently Asked Questions on NRI Return Filing
When is an NRI required to file an income tax return in India?
Filing is mandatory where total income from Indian sources exceeds the basic exemption limit applicable to the chosen tax regime, computed before deductions. It is also necessary, though not strictly mandatory, wherever tax deducted at source exceeds the actual liability and a refund is sought, where capital losses are to be carried forward, where a treaty benefit is being claimed formally, or where a capital gains reinvestment exemption is being availed on the sale of Indian property.
Which ITR form should a non-resident use?
ITR-2 is the correct form for most non-residents, covering rental income, capital gains on shares, mutual funds and property, interest on NRO deposits and dividends. ITR-3 applies where the non-resident has business or professional income arising in India. ITR-1 is not available to a non-resident, so a return filed on it will be treated as defective even if the income figures are otherwise correct.
Do NRIs have to disclose foreign assets and overseas bank accounts?
No. The requirement to report foreign assets in Schedule FA and foreign income in Schedule FSI applies only to an individual who is resident and ordinarily resident. A non-resident, and a person who is resident but not ordinarily resident, is outside that requirement and reports only India-sourced income in the Indian return.
Can a non-resident opt for the new tax regime?
Yes. A non-resident may compute tax under the concessional regime, which applies lower slab rates but withdraws most deductions including those for specified investments, health insurance and the standard deduction against salary. Which regime produces a lower liability depends on the deductions actually available, so the comparison should be run on the individual's own figures before the return is filed rather than assumed from general advice.
What happens if a non-resident misses the filing deadline?
The immediate consequence is the loss of the right to carry forward capital losses, which cannot be restored. A belated return may be filed by the end of the assessment year with a late fee under Section 234F and interest under Section 234A on any unpaid tax. Beyond that, an updated return may be filed within the period allowed under Section 139(8A) on payment of additional tax, but a refund cannot be claimed through an updated return.
Tax Deducted on Your Indian Income?
Most of it is usually refundable, but only if you file. Speak to our Pune team.
- 📞 +91 98219 32683 | +91 97650 00966
- 💬 WhatsApp +91 98190 00511
- ✉ info@ndsavla.in
- 📍 Baner Business Bay, S No 52, Pashan–Sus Rd, behind Audi, Baner, Pune 411045
- 🕐 Monday–Saturday | 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM